Introduction
If you and your pup like surprises, a Super Chewer subscription from the makers of BarkBox won’t disappoint. This package is filled with toys and snacks designed for dogs who vigorously enjoy their gifts, as opposed to the standard box which might be filled with less durable plush toys. Whether you have a chewy Chihuahua or a chomping Labrador Retriever, the Super Chewer box is the way to go if you want toys that are built to last a long time — or at least until the next box arrives. The Pool Party Animals box is a great example of what subscribers can expect, packed with cool stuff that both dogs and their owners will enjoy.
Super Chewer Reviewed
Who Makes Super Chewer and Where Is It Produced?
Super Chewer is a more durable line of toys made by BARK, which offers the BarkBox toy and treat subscription service for dogs. BARK is based in New York, but receives toys from all around the world. Their treats and chews are made exclusively in the USA and Canada from domestic and imported ingredients. Typically, the food items have a 24-month shelf life, so they’ll last a long while in case your dog doesn’t chomp through them all by the time the next box arrives.
Which Type of Dog Is BARK Super Chewer Best Suited For?
Super Chewer is a premium line of toys made to be even more durable than the regular BarkBox toys so that they’ll survive through the toughest play sessions. These toys are backed by a promise of replacement if your dog manages to destroy them sooner than expected. There’s no time limit, but one important thing to note is that BARK doesn’t accept returns or exchanges for a monetary refund. If your dog simply doesn’t like their box, you can contact BARK for a similar replacement toy. You can also let them know about your dog’s preferences so that they’ll have a better idea of what to include in your next box.
What to Expect from a Super Chewer Box
Each month, you’ll receive a box in a surprise theme tailored to your dog’s preferences. The Super Chewer box comes with two toys, two chews, and two treats, but you can upgrade the box for an extra toy or treat to avoid paying the shipping fees. Because it’s a Super Chewer — not a regular BarkBox — you won’t find squeaker toys or stuffies. Instead, they’ll typically send durable nylon or rubber toys along with two chews and two bags of snacks.
You can choose your first month’s theme from a selection of two, or you can begin your subscription with a mystery box. After your first month, you’ll receive a box with surprise toys and treats every time.
How Much Does Super Chewer Cost?
The Super Chewer plan costs a little more than a standard BarkBox because it contains higher-quality toys for heavier chewers. If you’re on a budget, you can order a half-box plan for $19.99, or buy a full box for a reduced price if you pay annually or every six months instead of monthly.
Monthly Billing (prices in USD)
| Plan | 1-Month | 6-Month | 12-Month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Super Chewer | $45 | $35 | $30 |
| Super Chewer Extra Toy | $55 ($45 + $9) | $44 ($35 + $9) | $39 ($30 + $9) |
| Super Chewer Lite | $19.99 | $19.99 | $19.99 |
BARK claims that every month they send at least $44 worth of toys, so the box pays for itself every time. Plus, unlike your local pet store, BARK will replace your dog’s toy if they manage to destroy it — no matter how long it takes. However, they don’t accept returns or exchanges for a monetary refund.
Can I Buy the Items Separately?
Yes and no. If there was a particular toy from a previous box that your pup was super excited about, you can sometimes purchase an extra one separately online at the Bark Shop. However, themed items are only available until they sell out, so you’ll have to act fast if your pup has a new favorite.
Can I Choose What’s in My Super Chewer Box?
You can ask BARK to send you more of a certain type of product. For example, if your dog showed little interest in a particular toy, you can request a different type they might enjoy more. You can also ask to avoid certain allergens — for instance, letting them know you don’t want any treats containing beef. You can’t choose exactly what goes in your package, but the unknown is part of the fun. A Super Chewer box is like a box of chocolates, and you never know what your pup will get.
What About the Quality of the Treats and Chews?
All edible items are made in the United States or Canada from domestic and imported ingredients. BARK never uses corn, wheat, or soy in their products, and they’ll also avoid sending recipes with ingredients that your dog is allergic to or doesn’t like, as long as you let them know the month before.
Reviews of the Pool Party Animal-Themed Super Chewer Box
The Pool Party Animal-themed box contained three toys, chosen by selecting the extra toy option instead of paying for shipping. The Super Chewer plan starts at $19.99 for Super Chewer Lite — which includes one toy, one chew, and one bag of treats — and goes up to $45 for a full box. You can add an extra toy or bag of treats for only $9 more to qualify for free shipping, or save money by paying annually ($30/month) or every six months ($35/month). The Super Chewer Lite plan remains $19.99 every month regardless of billing frequency.
The box included three toys: the Flamboyant Flamingo, Fetchin’ Rays, and Drool Pool Noodle. It also contained two chews — Chicken Stick Recipe by Pur Love and Pumpkin & Honey Recipe by The Pet Gourmet — and two bags of treats: Jerky Nibbles Turkey & Sweet Potato Recipe and Jerky Bar Salmon Recipe, both by BarkEats.
1. The Flamboyant Flamingo
The Flamboyant Flamingo is a durable rubber chew toy shaped like a flamingo. It held up well through enthusiastic play sessions and kept the dog engaged for a solid stretch of time — a strong start to the themed box.
2. Fetchin’ Rays
The Fetchin’ Rays toy is designed for interactive fetch play. Its durable construction made it a good fit for a heavy chewer, and its shape made it easy to toss and retrieve during outdoor play.
3. Drool Pool Noodle
The Drool Pool Noodle rounds out the pool party theme with a fun, noodle-inspired design. Like the other toys in the box, it’s built to withstand aggressive chewing while still being engaging enough to hold a dog’s attention.
4. Chicken Stick Recipe by Pur Love
This single-ingredient chew was a hit. Made in the USA, it kept the dog occupied and was consumed eagerly — a good sign for picky chewers looking for a simple, quality treat.
5. Pumpkin & Honey Recipe by The Pet Gourmet
A softer chew option, the Pumpkin & Honey Recipe offered a different texture and flavor profile. Dogs who enjoy sweeter, gentler chews will likely appreciate this one as a complement to the meatier options.
6. Jerky Nibbles Turkey & Sweet Potato Recipe by BarkEats
These bite-sized jerky treats were easy to use as rewards during training or simply as a snack. The turkey and sweet potato combination is a common allergen-friendly pairing that most dogs tend to enjoy.
7. Jerky Bar Salmon Recipe by BarkEats
The salmon jerky bar offered a protein-rich treat with a strong aroma that dogs find appealing. It’s a good option for dogs who do well with fish-based proteins and adds variety to the treat lineup in the box.
Final Thoughts
The BARK Super Chewer box delivers solid value for owners of heavy chewers. With durable toys, quality chews, and treats made in the USA and Canada, each monthly box offers something new to keep dogs entertained and engaged. The ability to customize around allergies and toy preferences — combined with BARK’s no-questions replacement policy — makes it a low-risk subscription worth trying for dogs who tend to destroy their toys faster than most.
